September 11, 2009
Devon Cajuste WR/Punter (Holy Cross)
Anthony Brunetti RB/LB (Holy Trinity)
Steven Browne RB/CB (Bishop Ford)

September 18, 2009
Hakim Rice TB/LB (St. Peter's)
Dean Marlowe QB/S (Holy Cross)
Andrew Armato RB (St. Joseph by the Sea)

September 25, 2009
Anthony Dilorenzo QB (Kellenberg)
Michael Viegas RB/WR (Monsignor Farrell)
Matthew Wilson G/NG (Holy Trinity)
Bruce Grant RB (Fordham Prep)

October 3, 2009
J.C. Woods RB (St. Anthony's)
Tyrell Goodman QB (Stepinac)
Paul Mitton OT/DE (Holy Trinity)

October 10, 2009
Lyle McCombs (St. Joseph)
Gary Acquah (Mt. St. Michael's)
Frank Antetomaso (Kellenberg)
Jeremiah Kobena (Cardinal Hayes)

 October 17, 2009
Chris Mattina (Xavier)
Chris Brathwaite (Holy Cross)
Josh Powell (Stepinac)

October 24, 2009
    Jesse Signa (St. Anthony's)
Jack Wilson (Xavier)
Max Kinder (Fordham Prep)

October 31, 2009
    Brian Caffrey (St. Francis Prep)
Devante Bryant (Holy Cross)
Tyrae Woodson - Samuels (Iona  Prep)

November 7, 2009
    James Leavy (Monsignor Farrell)
Michael Dunkley (Iona Prep)
Brendan Stackpole (St. Francis Prep)
Angel Cordero (Bishop Ford)

November 14, 2009
    Tarik  Hawkins (Mount Saint Michael)
Anthony  Brunetti (Holy Trinity)
Tom  Schrieber (St. Anthony’s)
Kwamayne Davis (Cardinal Hayes)

CHAMPIONSHIP MOST VALUABLE PLAYERS
    A –  Hakim Rice (St. Peter’s)
AA - Jahi Grannell (Mount Saint Michael)
AAA - Tim Wine (St. Anthony's)

Thanksgiving
John Gearity (Xavier)